Generation comparison

Toyota GR86 2nd Generation (2022-present) vs Subaru Brz 2nd Generation (2022-present)

Toyota GR86 2nd Generation (2022-present) studio view

2nd Generation · 2022-present

Toyota GR86

VS
Subaru Brz 2nd Generation (2022-present) studio view

2nd Generation · 2022-present

Subaru Brz

Reliability30% weight
8.2/10

11.17 ODI reports were recorded per 10,000 EWR-produced vehicles. “Engine stall or loss of power” is the most frequently matched narrative (5 reports).

8.7/10

9.91 ODI reports were recorded per 10,000 EWR-produced vehicles. “Engine stall or loss of power” is the most frequently matched narrative (2 reports).

Energy cost15% weight
8.1/10

EPA estimates $3,150–$3,450 in annual energy cost for the latest configurations. Comparable vehicles average $3,852.

8.6/10

EPA estimates $3,050–$3,450 in annual energy cost for the latest configurations. Comparable vehicles average $3,846.

Handling10% weight
9.0/10

Low mass, excellent balance and immediate direction changes make the GR86 the most playful car here, though its steering is accurate rather than richly communicative.

8.9/10

Exceptional balance, accuracy and body control place the BRZ near the top of this group, with reduced steering feedback the only meaningful dynamic weakness.

Comfort8% weight
6.1/10

Supportive sports seats help, but firm suspension, highway noise, and the low driving environment prioritize engagement over relaxation.

6.5/10

Supportive seats and slightly road-friendlier tuning help, but noise and firm sports-car responses remain unavoidable.

Roominess7% weight
4.3/10

Front occupants fit reasonably well, but the rear seats, storage, cargo opening, and low access remain sports-coupe compromises.

4.3/10

Front-seat packaging is workable, while rear seats and daily storage are nominal rather than genuinely accommodating.

Onboard electronics5% weight
5.4/10

The simple controls are easy to operate, but wired phone integration, modest graphics, and limited feature depth were already behind the 2024 market.

5.6/10

The interface is simple and usable, but its 8-inch hardware and wired connectivity are basic against the wider 2024 market.

Final scoreSubaru Brz leads
7.5/10head-to-head score
7.9/10head-to-head score

See how QuickCarFixes calculates and compares scores.

NHTSA ODI complaints

Reliability and recurring problems

Toyota GR86

Reliability
8.2/10
ODI reports
54
Reports per 10,000 produced
11.17
Severe-event share
5.6%

Most frequently matched narratives

  1. Engine stall or loss of power5
  2. Suspension noise or failure2

Subaru Brz

Reliability
8.7/10
ODI reports
17
Reports per 10,000 produced
9.91
Severe-event share
0%

Most frequently matched narratives

  1. Engine stall or loss of power2
NHTSA safety data

Crash-test coverage and recalls

Toyota GR86

NCAP score
Not rated
Latest rated model year
Not rated
Recall campaigns
2
Completion rates reported
2/2
Median reported completion
81.1%
Park-it / park-outside campaigns
0 / 0

Subaru Brz

NCAP score
Not rated
Latest rated model year
Not rated
Recall campaigns
1
Completion rates reported
1/1
Median reported completion
63.2%
Park-it / park-outside campaigns
0 / 0
EPA FuelEconomy.gov

Annual energy cost against comparable vehicles

Toyota GR86

Energy-cost score
8.1/10
EPA model year
2025
Estimated annual energy cost
$3,150–$3,450
Comparable-class average
$3,852
Difference from comparable average
-$702–-$402

Subaru Brz

Energy-cost score
8.6/10
EPA model year
2026
Estimated annual energy cost
$3,050–$3,450
Comparable-class average
$3,846
Difference from comparable average
-$796–-$396
Documented editorial review

Handling, comfort, space and onboard electronics

Toyota GR86

Handling
9.0/10
Comfort
6.1/10
Roominess
4.3/10
Onboard electronics
5.4/10

Subaru Brz

Handling
8.9/10
Comfort
6.5/10
Roominess
4.3/10
Onboard electronics
5.6/10