Nissan Frontier 3rd Generation (2022-present) vs Toyota Tacoma 4th Generation (2024-present)

9.96 ODI reports were recorded per 10,000 EWR-produced vehicles. “Engine stall or loss of power” is the most frequently matched narrative (52 reports).

5.43 ODI reports were recorded per 10,000 EWR-produced vehicles. “Transmission hesitation or failure” is the most frequently matched narrative (21 reports).

The latest rated model year is 2022, with 4 stars. QuickCarFixes converts the conservative configuration result to its 10-point scale.

The latest rated model year is 2025, with 4 stars. QuickCarFixes converts the conservative configuration result to its 10-point scale.

EPA estimates $2,950–$3,400 in annual energy cost for the latest configurations. Comparable vehicles average $3,189–$3,788.

EPA estimates $2,650–$3,100 in annual energy cost for the latest configurations. Comparable vehicles average $2,613–$3,255.

The Frontier is stable and predictable, but heavy low-speed steering and a less polished chassis make it harder work than the newer Ranger or unibody Maverick.

The Tacoma feels stable and easier to place than its predecessor, with controlled body movement; steering feedback remains filtered and off-road tires soften response.

Excellent front-seat support carries the Frontier over long distances, while highway noise and a traditionally truck-like ride keep the overall result short of luxury territory.

The redesigned driving position and ride are better than before, but seat comfort remains polarizing and off-road trims can feel busy on broken pavement.

The front row is accommodating, but rear legroom and behind-seat storage trail the roomier midsize pickups.

Front occupants get useful adjustment, but the Double Cab rear bench loses the contest for adult legroom and cabin storage is only average for a midsize truck.

The interface is simple and stable, and later models add a larger screen and wireless integration; the analog-heavy cabin still lacks the display breadth of newer rivals.

The optional 14-inch screen is crisp and feature-rich, but the base display is less impressive and owner reports of slow starts or connectivity glitches reduce the stability mark.