Generation comparison

Toyota Tundra 3rd Generation (2022-present) vs Toyota Tacoma 4th Generation (2024-present)

Toyota Tundra 3rd Generation (2022-present) studio view

3rd Generation · 2022-present

Toyota Tundra

233.6″–252.5″ L × 80.2″ W × 78.0″–78.3″ H · 145.7″–164.6″ wheelbase

VS
Toyota Tacoma 4th Generation (2024-present) studio view

4th Generation · 2024-present

Toyota Tacoma

213.0″–226.2″ L × 76.9″–77.9″ W × 73.8″–74.7″ H · 131.9″–145.1″ wheelbase

Reliability30% weight
2.3/10

33.83 ODI reports were recorded per 10,000 EWR-produced vehicles. “Engine stall or loss of power” is the most frequently matched narrative (300 reports).

9.7/10

5.43 ODI reports were recorded per 10,000 EWR-produced vehicles. “Transmission hesitation or failure” is the most frequently matched narrative (21 reports).

NCAP safety25% weight
10.0/10

The latest rated model year is 2025, with 5 stars. QuickCarFixes converts the conservative configuration result to its 10-point scale.

8.0/10

The latest rated model year is 2025, with 4 stars. QuickCarFixes converts the conservative configuration result to its 10-point scale.

Energy cost15% weight
4.3/10

EPA estimates $2,800–$4,000 in annual energy cost for the latest configurations. Comparable vehicles average $3,060–$3,788.

4.4/10

EPA estimates $2,650–$3,100 in annual energy cost for the latest configurations. Comparable vehicles average $2,613–$3,255.

Handling10% weight
7.1/10

The coil-spring chassis is settled and predictable for a full-size pickup, but slow responses and the broad footprint limit agility in tighter roads and parking lots.

7.8/10

The Tacoma feels stable and easier to place than its predecessor, with controlled body movement; steering feedback remains filtered and off-road tires soften response.

Comfort8% weight
8.4/10

The coil-spring rear suspension gives this full-size truck a settled ride, and the broad front seats work well over distance; tire and TRD-package choices still affect noise and firmness.

7.1/10

The redesigned driving position and ride are better than before, but seat comfort remains polarizing and off-road trims can feel busy on broken pavement.

Roominess7% weight
8.7/10

CrewMax rear space is genuinely adult-sized and the front cabin is broad, though the tall step-in and hybrid battery packaging reduce some practical space.

5.9/10

Front occupants get useful adjustment, but the Double Cab rear bench loses the contest for adult legroom and cabin storage is only average for a midsize truck.

Onboard electronics5% weight
8.3/10

The available 14-inch interface and wireless integration look current and respond quickly, but several common functions demand screen interaction and equipment differs sharply by trim.

7.7/10

The optional 14-inch screen is crisp and feature-rich, but the base display is less impressive and owner reports of slow starts or connectivity glitches reduce the stability mark.

Final scoreToyota Tacoma leads
6.2/10head-to-head score
7.7/10head-to-head score

Scores use federal safety and ownership data plus documented editorial ratings. Learn how QuickCarFixes calculates and compares scores here.

NHTSA ODI complaints

Reliability and recurring problems

Toyota Tundra

Reliability
2.3/10
ODI reports
2,041
Reports per 10,000 produced
33.83
Severe-event share
2.4%

Most frequently matched narratives

  1. Engine stall or loss of power300
  2. Brake failure or reduced braking44
  3. Infotainment or display blackout36
  4. Transmission hesitation or failure34
  5. Premature or uneven tire wear24

Toyota Tacoma

Reliability
9.7/10
ODI reports
314
Reports per 10,000 produced
5.43
Severe-event share
6.1%

Most frequently matched narratives

  1. Transmission hesitation or failure21
  2. Engine stall or loss of power19
  3. Brake failure or reduced braking17
  4. Infotainment or display blackout11
  5. Door, hatch, or latch failure9
NHTSA safety data

Crash-test coverage and recalls

Toyota Tundra

NCAP score
10.0/10
Latest rated model year
2025
Recall campaigns
22
Completion rates reported
19/22
Median reported completion
97.4%
Park-it / park-outside campaigns
0 / 0

Toyota Tacoma

NCAP score
8.0/10
Latest rated model year
2025
Recall campaigns
6
Completion rates reported
4/6
Median reported completion
63.8%
Park-it / park-outside campaigns
0 / 0
EPA FuelEconomy.gov

Annual energy cost against comparable vehicles

Toyota Tundra

Energy-cost score
4.3/10
EPA model year
2026
Estimated annual energy cost
$2,800–$4,000
Comparable-class average
$3,060–$3,788
Difference from comparable average
-$538–$745

Toyota Tacoma

Energy-cost score
4.4/10
EPA model year
2026
Estimated annual energy cost
$2,650–$3,100
Comparable-class average
$2,613–$3,255
Difference from comparable average
-$605–$281
Documented editorial review

Handling, comfort, space and onboard electronics

Toyota Tundra

Handling
7.1/10
Comfort
8.4/10
Roominess
8.7/10
Onboard electronics
8.3/10

Toyota Tacoma

Handling
7.8/10
Comfort
7.1/10
Roominess
5.9/10
Onboard electronics
7.7/10